Why “axioms” is being discussed
The most recent Hacker News stories and comments contributing to this topic's mentions.
Certainly. But the underlying assumption here is that physics do work reasonably well, arguing otherwise is epistemology and has it's place in philosophy more than in physics. T…
by fyltr · Nov 22, 2026
Is it even true that there is a step of faith? We have many proofs given a set of axioms. But those axioms aren’t even taken on faith as much as they are assumed to be true. In…
by stouset · Nov 22, 2026
Yes it does. Sets could be represented in Martin Lof type theory and all the ZFC axioms proven inside it. If ZFC is inconsistent, then so would be the type theory.
by YetAnotherNick · Nov 22, 2026
This is a very good question! There are two answers. First off, you can absolutely do what you are describing. There are systems like Metamath that assume nothing beyond first-o…
by alethic · Nov 22, 2026
No. Those aspirations are not possible. Mathematics cannot be reduced to pure logic alone - you have to assume something. However we are now extremely clear on what you need to…
by btilly · Nov 22, 2026
Yes, which is why “The AI only proved this because it was in the training data somewhere” is rather a cop-out. The axioms are “in the training data” for all of us, human or bot,…
by mpyne · Nov 22, 2026
Interest
Proportion of Hacker News items mentioning "axioms" over time.
Mentions
Total number of Hacker News items mentioning "axioms" over time.